Public-Private Partnerships for Infrastructure in China - PPPI Series 2009 (Event 2)
Agenda

Welcome Remarks and Introduction

Moderator: Zhang Nianyu, Division Director, National Development Reform Committee (NDRC) Training Center

Du Ping, Director General, National Development and Reform Commission Training Center
Phil Karp, World Bank Institute Regional Coordinator
Elaine Glennie, Senior Capacity Building Specialist, Asian Development Bank Institute

Keynote Speech: Reform in China's Investment System

• Presentation: Reform in China's Investment System [ PDF 46.3KB | 10 pages ]

Speaker: Yang Ping, Professor, Division Director, Investment Institute, NDRC

• Direction and Key Elements of Infrastructure Investment Institutional Reform in China
• Legal and Regulatory Framework for PPPI

Discussant: Xie Jiaping, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics

Coffee Break

Session 1: Fundamentals of PPPI

Moderator: Zhang Nianyu, Division Director, NDRC Training Center

Speaker: Wang Shouqing, Professor, Tsinghua University

• Concept, Meaning, Comparison with Traditional Models, Pros and Cons, and Application of PPPI
• PPPI's Application in China and Abroad, and its Importance to Infrastructure in China
• Structure, Main Participants and Contract of PPPI Project

• English: Fundamentals of PPPI [ PDF 386.7KB | 54 pages ]
• Chinese: 基础设施/公用事业特许经营项目融资 [ PDF 465KB | 52 pages ]

Discussant: Sun Hui, Tianjin University

Q&A

Session 2: PPPI's Application in China

Moderator: Wang Shouqing, Professor, Tsinghua University

Speaker: Qin Hong, Deputy Director, Ministry of Construction

• Application of PPPI in China, and Experiences and Lessons of Government
• Laws and Regulations and Government's Supervision in China

• English: PPPI's Application in China [ PDF 600.8KB | 24 pages ]
• Chinese: PPP在中国的实践与政府监管 [ PDF 696KB | 24 pages ]

Discussant: Qi Xia, Tsinghua University

Coffee Break

Session 3: PPPI Institutional Framework

Moderator: Wang Shouqing, Professor, Tsinghua University

Speaker: Junglim Hahm, PSD Specialist, World Bank

• Overview of the Public Sector Entities Involved in PPPI Development
• Role of these Public Sector Parties and their Relationships
• International Experience in PPPI Units, their Models, Pros and Cons, and Functions.

• English: PPPI Institutional Framework [ PDF 967.5KB | 32 pages ]

Discussant: Jose L. Guasch, Senior Advisor, World Bank

Q&A

Session 4: Risk Management of PPP Projects

Moderator: Sheng Li, Senior Learning Specialist, WBI

Speaker: Ye Sudong, Professor, Jiaotong University

• Overview and Categorization of PPPI Project Risks
• Optimal Risk Sharing Principle and Risk Matrix
• Risk Management by Government and Important Contractual Issues, such as Duration of Franchise, Design of Price Adjustment Formula

• English: Risk Management of PPP Projects [ PDF 313.3KB | 48 pages ]
• Chinese: PPP项目的风险管理 [ PDF 408KB | 56 pages ]

Discussant: Fan Zhiqing, Tianjin University

Coffee Break

Session 5: Value for Money (VFM) and Public Sector Comparator (PSC)

Moderator: Sheng Li, Senior Learning Specialist, WBI

Speaker: Kylee Anastasi, Consultant, World Bank

• Establishment and Application of Public Sector Comparator (PSC)
• How to Judge the Applicability of PPPI and Select Specific Model
• Key Elements in Invitation for Bidding, Evaluation and Selection of Private Partnership

• English: Value for Money (VFM) and Public Sector Comparator (PSC) [ PDF 1.1MB | 40 pages ]

Discussant: Jose L. Guasch, Senior Advisor, World Bank

Q&A

Session 6: Financing PPP

Moderator: Sheng Li, Senior Learning Specialist, WBI

Speaker: David Roberts, Macquarie Bank

• International Experiences and Lessons of Financing PPPI
• How to Finance PPPI under Current Financial Crisis

• English: Financing PPP [ PDF 621.6KB | 31 pages ]
• Chinese: 推动公私合营有效融资的主要策略 世界银行/发改委会议 [ PDF 893KB | 31 pages ]

Discussant: Junglim Hahm, PSD Specialist, World Bank

Coffee Break

Session 7: Legal Framework for PPP and International Best Practices

Moderator: Sheng Li, Senior Learning Specialist, WBI

Speakers:
Mark Moseley, Senior. Counsel, World Bank
Stephen Harder, Clifford Chance

• Composition of Legal Framework for PPPI
• Key Elements of Concession Law
• Key Elements of Bidding Documents
• Key Elements of Concession Agreement

• English: Legal Framework for PPP and International Best Practices [ PDF 128.5KB | 18 pages ]

Discussant: Stephen Harder, Clifford Chance

Q&A

Session 8: PPPI Procurement: Bid Invitation and Evaluation

Moderator: Elaine Glennie, Capacity Building Specialist, ADBI

Speakers:

Ian. P.J. Nightingale, Lead Procurement Specialist, World Bank

• English: Procurement of Public-Private Partnerships [ PDF 532.1KB | 23 pages ]

Kang-Soo Kim, Head of PPP Division, Public-Private Infrastructure Investment Management Center (PIMAC), Korean Development Institute

• English: Procurement Process and Evaluation of PPP Projects in Korea [ PDF 1003.5KB | 42 pages ]

Kylee Anastasi, Consultant, World Bank

• English: PPPI Procurement, Bid Invitation and Evaluation [ PDF 582.7KB | 19 pages ]

• How Government Can Plan, Select and Prioritize Infrastructure Projects in Consideration of Both Public and Private Infrastructure
• The Role of the Government in the Up-Front Decisions of Bidding Invitation and Evaluation
• PPP Procurement Allowing the Maximum Benefit from Competition
• Introduction of the Concept of Value for Money and its Importance

Coffee Break

Session 9: Performance Management of PPP Projects

Moderator: Elaine Glennie, Capacity Building Specialist, ADBI

Speaker: Jose L. Guasch, Sr. Advisor, World Bank

• Discussion of Typical Issues Arising After Concession is Awarded
• Model Review of the PPP Performance Management Designed to Deal with these Issues
• Empirical Review of Latin American Concessions and Korean PPP Contracts and their Performance

• English: Performance Management of PPP Projects [ PDF 570.7KB | 74 pages ]

Discussant: Mark Moseley, Senior Counsel, World Bank

Q&A

Session 10: Case Study 1- Water Project

Moderator: Wang Shouqing, Professor, Tsinghua University

Speaker: Zhang Liao, General Manager of Ji Bang

• Water Project on PPPI: Key Elements of Application, Experiences and Lessons
• Coordination and Administration by Government
• Revelation and Suggestion to Government

• English: Case Study 1: Water Project [ PDF 1.3MB | 51 pages ]
• Chinese: 水务PPP项目操作实务 [ PDF 1.5MB | 51 pages ]

Discussant: Wang Qiang, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics

Coffee Break

Session 11: Case Study 2- Urban Transport Project

Moderator: Wang Shouqing, Professor, Tsinghua University

Speaker: Li Kaimeng, Director, China International Engineering Consulting Corp.

• Transport Project on PPPI: Key Elements of Application, Experiences and Lessons
• Coordination and Administration by Government
• Recommendations to Government

• English: Case Study 2: Urban Transport Project [ PDF 3.5MB | 55 pages ]
• Chinese: PPP在中国：在变通中探寻出路——以交通项目为例 [ PDF 3.7MB | 55 pages ]

Discussant: John Scales, China Transport Sector Coordinator, World Bank

Q&A

Participant Evaluation

Summary and Closing Remarks
- Du Ping, Director General, NDRC Training Center
- Jose L. Guasch, Senior Advisor, World Bank
- Elaine Glennie, Capacity Building Specialist, ADBI